It's not that bad.
I think it's the chin that actually spoils it. It's a roundish chin, riffing off Karl Urban (which is fair enough) but positioned how it is in that big head makes him look like he's got a double chin.
On the other hand, the Pop! Heroes Judge Dredd, doesn't even have a slash for a mouth, a mis-step, I think, although I am fond of that figure. (He looks great next to a similar Darth Vader figure on my shelf. Hee hee.)
As an example of a Pop Vinyl type thing with a movie Dredd uniform, I think it's okay, from the little I've seen. I think I'd be happy to get one.